Skip to main content

You are here

JD

Just ahead of the Thanksgiving holiday, another 401(k) plan fiduciary was sued for excessive fees and an allegedly imprudent selection of target-date funds. The plaintiffs here[1]—Cheyenne Jones and Sara J. Gast, former employees of independent bottler Coca-Cola Consolidated Inc. and current... READ MORE
It was a short week, but a busy one for the Labor Department, as it dropped off a second final rule at the OMB for evaluation.  The final rule on “Fiduciary Duties Regarding Proxy Voting and Shareholder Rights” was received at the Office and Management Budget on Nov. 25, just a day after the final... READ MORE
A suit which had alleged that a profit-sharing plan’s investment allocation was “inappropriate” and the plan fiduciaries’ actions in establishing and maintaining it imprudent has settled. The settlement (Toomey v. DeMoulas Super Markets, Inc., D. Mass., No. 1:19-cv-11633, motion for settlement... READ MORE
In a year chock-full of proposed rules and final regulations, the Labor Department has apparently wrapped up its work on a new fiduciary rule. According to a posting on the Office of Management and Budget website, the DOL on Nov. 24 dropped off its final rule on its proposed advice package, “... READ MORE
Thanksgiving has been called a “uniquely American” holiday—and so, even in a year in which there has been an unprecedented amount of disruption, stress, discomfort and loss—there remains so much for which to be thankful.  I’m thankful that so many employers (still) voluntarily choose to offer a... READ MORE
A primary sponsor of the SECURE Act—and Chairman of the House Ways & Means Committee—has a bone to pick with the Labor Department and a key assumption in its interim final rules regarding lifetime disclosures. In a letter to Secretary of Labor Eugene Scalia, Rep. Richie Neal (D-MA), a sponsor... READ MORE
The “more harm than good” standard once again proves to be too high a burden for plaintiffs in a stock drop suit—but defendants didn’t need to go “there.” This suit (Burke v. Boeing Co., N.D. Ill., No. 1:19-cv-02203, 11/12/20) had been filed by plaintiffs Diane Burke, Alex Proestakis, Miguel A.... READ MORE
Those who had hoped for some clarity—or perhaps a shift—in the standards involving where, and how, to draw the line between the obligations of corporate officials and ERISA plan fiduciaries—well, the Supreme Court has decided (again) not to provide it. It’s an issue that the U.S. Supreme Court had... READ MORE
Citing the “absence of any evidence indicating actual confusion in the marketplace,” a federal judge has decided in favor of the American Retirement Association (parent organization of NAPA) in litigation brought by the CFA Institute regarding use of the NAPA CPFA credential. On Nov. 5, the U.S.... READ MORE
If you have turned on a TV, walked by a radio, driven down a residential street, or answered a phone (or more likely let it go unanswered) in the past month, you will, of course, be aware that our nation officially went to the polls.  Of course, our nation was “going” to the polls—or at least... READ MORE
Another multibillion-dollar 401(k) has been targeted in a fiduciary breach suit—but this time the focus isn’t fees, but the choice of target-date funds, and their alleged “abysmal underperformance.” The suit (Cutrone v. Allstate Corp., N.D. Ill., No. 1:20-cv-06463, complaint 10/30/20) has been... READ MORE
Halloween is the time of year when one’s thoughts turn to trick-or-treat, ghosts and goblins, and things that go bump in the night. And sometimes it’s just a good time to think about the things that give us pause—that cause a chill to run down our spine.  In that category, here are three things to... READ MORE
The final rule on ESG investing by ERISA plans steps away from the proposed rule’s focus on ESG. Indeed, the Department of Labor (DOL) notes that “unlike the proposal, the final rule’s operative text contains no specific references to ESG or ESG-themed funds.”  Rather, acknowledging the fluid... READ MORE
A reader recently commented, “Nevin: You are continually berating those who question various aspects of 401(k) plans as if the current structure is ‘perfect.’ It isn’t.” That comment was inspired by a recent column of mine critical of a proposal rumored to be under contemplation by the Biden... READ MORE
Another massive 401(k) plan has been targeted with an excessive fee suit, alleging a lack of RFPs, overpriced recordkeeping and managed accounts and self-dealing.  The suit (Guyes et al. v. Nestle USA Inc. et al., case number 1:20-cv-01560), brought in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern... READ MORE
Noting that the settlement agreement is “fair, reasonable, and adequate, and within the range of possible approval,” the parties in an excessive fee suit have come to terms. More specifically, on Oct. 12, 2020, “after extensive litigation, lengthy discovery,[1] and protracted arm’s-length... READ MORE
Another week, another Bloomberg op-ed bashing 401(k)s—but this time the target is fees—and advisors. The most recent “shot” is found in an article[1] titled “401(k) Fees Are Eating Your Retirement Savings.” The author, one Ethan Schwartz,[2] without citation (beyond “various estimates”), tosses... READ MORE
In a year full of challenges for plans and plan sponsors alike, we’ve seen a spate of litigation against retirement programs like none in recent memory. So what’s a plan fiduciary to do?  At times, it seems that every plan in American with more than $1 billion in assets has fallen short of at... READ MORE
A different set of plaintiffs tried a (slightly) different approach (with different attorneys) in an excessive fee suit—but got the same result. The defendant in this instance was Trader Joe’s Company Retirement Plan, who had been sued for a variety of alleged fiduciary ills back in 2019 by former... READ MORE
Determining that the decision to pursue litigation was “objectively reckless,” a federal judge has sanctioned the law firm of Schlichter Bogard & Denton with a fine of (up to) $1.5 million. “When dealing with a lawyer, the courts ‘are entitled to demand that an attorney exhibit some judgment.... READ MORE

Pages